Tag Archives: china construction bank

China Bank Rally Takes A Breather

After a series of moves and reviews, the big 5 Chinese banks blasted upwards in February, outpacing the rocketing Hang Seng.  Over the past couple of days, however, they’ve retrenched.   If Morgan Stanley and Short trading interest are to be believed, this is a temporary reversal.

The banks include:

Name Acronym HK symbol
Industrial & Commercial Bank of China ICBC 1398
China Construction Bank CCB 939
Agricultural Bank of China ABC 1288
Bank of China BOC 3988
Bank of Communications BOCOM 3328

Despite rising Non performing loans, shrinking net interest margins and capital requirements, these banks have surpassed the rising Hang Seng thanks to interest rate rises, increased lending, China stimulus and PPI rises.


Timeline of positive factors:

1/24/2017 – Interest rates raised on medium term rates on loans.

2/03/2017 – Interest rates raised on short-term debt, reportedly in the interests of liquidity due to perceived resulting from the Chinese New Year.

2/14/2017 – Morgan Stanley published a bullish report on China Banks. Banks.

2/15/2017 – Bloomberg reported that options trading reacted positively to the bullish stance of Morgan Stanley on the big 4 banks, (all of banks listed above excluding BOCOM, which isn’t included in the  big 4).

None of these banks have reported annual earnings.  While earnings seasons has just about ended in the US, annual earnings reports for Hong Kong listed stocks are trickling in.  Regardless of the annual earnings, they won’t reflect the February 2017 change in interest rates and producer price inflation which Morgan Stanley reports.

Given the significant decline in short-term selling ratios for all but BOC, 3988 HK, the recent drop could signify a temporary drop versus a long-term decline.  At least for the short-term.






Hang Seng and Shanghai Comp Rise in Tandem

Despite disappointing retail sales numbers released over the weekend, the Hang Seng and China Comp managed to rise, following a weekly decline for both.


This could be blamed either on a short-term correction after falls over 10% from recent highs, or the usual stimulus hopes after weakening retail and credit numbers.

The HSI had positive moves in the majority of sectors.  For the HSCEI, however, the 10 decliners were dominated by banks.

hscei banks

Source: AA stocks


While China banks are under pressure with net interest income declining and, npl’s growing, the latest move could be due to rumors that Chinese regulators will be examining non-performing loan data.  Despite economic weakness in China, NPL’S have stayed relatively low.  While NPL’S have grown, criticism has come from outside regarding the drop in allowances to NPLS, now below the 150% guideline for 2 of the major 4 banks. From the last quarterly reports for China’s big-4 SOE banks:

banks npl

Whatever the reason for the rise in stock values, the quick rise in one company, based on recent and historical performance, is unwarranted.  Belle International, hk 1880, has risen over 14% since May 11.


Belle is a footwear and sportswear apparel retailer with 20,375 stores in Mainland China, Hong Kong and Macao.  Belle has felt the brunt of the Chinese economy slowdown with same store sales declining, particularly in their bigger footwear segment, where they have the most outlets and get the biggest net profit.

Belle chart

Source Data: HKEX filings

While they have yet to issue their annual report, the decline in same store sales has seriously hit the bottom line as a profit warning was issued on 3/29/2016,  stating the company expected a decline in annual net profit of 35% to 45%.  Without giving specific details, the company claimed it was due to declining same store sales, declining gross profit margins and goodwill impairment. This would represent a major decline in performance based on both the last semi-annual report and the last annual.

belle data

Source Data: HKEX filings

As shown above, the company is confronting 2 problems.  Thanks to declining sales in its original footwear core, it has been shifting more into sportswear apparel, which has continued to see same store increases although these are shrinking.  Unfortunately, the margins in sportswear apparel, where they sell mostly licensed goods versus proprietary goods as in footwear, are much lower than footwear.

Based on these trends and the recent profit warning, it is doubtful the company will meet the current projections for about a 20% decline in eps. The company is expecting to publish its annual report by the end of this month.



China Big4 Banks Surge on Rumoured Support

The Big 4 SOE banks of the PRC surged in Shanghai on reports of government intervention to prop up prices before this weekend’s annual policy meeting.  While the Shanghai Composite rose a mere .5%, the Shanghai 50, dominated by financials and energy,  increased by 3.36%.  The outsize volume for the Big 4 Banks reinforces the support comments made by anonymous sources.

Big 4 Volume.PNG

The gains in Shanghai, from over 2% to over 4%, were more robust than those in Hong Kong, none of which exceeded 2%. Still, with the bearish movements in Shanghai and Hong Kong, the stocks are generally well below the start of the year with the exception of Agricultural Bank of China, on the Shanghai exchange.

banks big 4 upd

Despite today’s changes and the rally from the 52-week lows, these shares have tumbled hard from their 52-week highs.  These 4 banks are among the top 10 in the world in terms of assets.  Even after today’s Shanghai shoot, the p/e’s of a couple of their peers in the top 10, BNP Paribas, p/e of 8.86; JP Morgan Chase, p/e 9.9 demonstrate the continued market skepticism toward these Banks and a China stimulus save.

Big 4 Banks pe

The 3rd quarter’s growth in NPL’s and flat to negative growth in net earnings reinforce this skepticism.

big 4 banks npls and net income.PNG

None of these banks have yet to report annual earnings.  Based on history, the banks will be reporting in late April.

Bank                                                  Last Annual Release

Agricultural Bank of China                           4/28/2015

China Construction Bank                              4/29/2015

Bank of China                                                    4/30/2015

Industrial & Commercial Bank                    5/5/2015


Shanghai/Hong Kong Bank Shares Diverge Again

As the PRC lowered down-payments for 1st and 2nd homes in China, the big 4 banks got different investor reactions based on their exchange.  Agricultural Bank of China, ABC, Bank of China, BOC, China Construction Bank, CCB and Industrial and Commercial Bank, ICBC, all rose moderately in Shanghai on Tuesday, maintaining their over 20% premiums to their Hong Kong listings.  Hong Kong declines in all four reflected a disbelief in the positive impact of this change, with drops from 1% fo 2.25%. Despite the Shanghai rise, the volumes were generally half the recent average. Hong Kong volume was just as thin with the exception of world banking behemoth, ICBC, with volume higher than the average.  Volume for all four on both exchanges has trickled compared to the peak in 2015 when volumes were in the billions.


China Banks upd

There have been no earnings updates for these four state-owned enterprises, with annual results generally coming around mid-April.  Last quarter reports, albeit with limited disclosure, were lackluster.  Increases in revenues were wiped out by increasing reported non-performing loans, npls, which were still reported at less than 2% with the exception of ABC which showed about 2.02%. Skeptics abound as to the truth in these percentages.

Big 4 Banks comps

Trailing p/e’s in Hong Kong, significantly below Shanghai, would point to bargains if it weren’t for:

  1. flat to slightly negative earnings after profit in the 9 months ending in September
  2. Reported NPLs continuing to shoot upwards
  3. Domestic economic contraction as shown by the sequential PMI data.

To name just a few reasons, assuming you accept the bank npl’s and the government data.

Currently, in terms of asset size, ICBC, CCB and ABC are the largest banks in the world, in descending order.  Including BOC, these four banks combined employ 1.6 billion, about equal to the 2013 population of Idaho. While US banks are infamous for layoffs in lean times, these SOE’s have made no layoff announcements in their filings or to the public.